When (Mahamana)Madan Mohan Malaviya ji Chose the Nation Over Moksha

A Man with a Giant Heart
Madan Mohan Malaviya once said something very special about how he wanted to live. He said:

“I do not want to be a king. I do not want to go to heaven. I only want one thing: to help people who are sad and in pain.”

What does this mean? Most people want power, money, or a happy life for themselves. But “Mahamana” was different.
He didn’t care about being famous or living in a palace.

He had a giant heart. He believed that the best thing a person can do is to be kind and help others feel better. This is why people called him “Mahamana,” which means “a person with a great mind and soul.”

“Why did the Mahamana set aside the desire for Moksha and place the nation above it?

To understand this, it becomes necessary to understand Moksha, Mahamana, and Moksha-dayini Kashi.” Kashi, the city that grants Moksha (spiritual freedom)

MOKSHA

In Indian philosophy, everything in this world is not permanent, and this is seen as the main reason for sorrow.

Life is a cycle of birth and death, and the world keeps changing. Freedom from this cycle and from ignorance is called moksha.

Moksha is the final goal of life. It means complete peace and freedom.

MAHAMANA

Madan Mohan Malaviya, fondly known as “Mahamana,” was one of the most respected leaders of India’s freedom struggle.

Mahatma Gandhi gave him the title “Mahamana” in recognition of his purity, discipline, and selfless devotion to the nation.

A visionary educationist, he was the founder of Banaras Hindu University (BHU), one of India’s largest and most prestigious institutions of higher learning.

He was elected President of the Indian National Congress four times, reflecting his influential leadership and national stature. Malaviya made lasting contributions to India’s political, social, and educational development.

In honour of his lifelong service, he was posthumously awarded the Bharat Ratna, India’s highest civilian honour, in 2014.

FOR MORE INFORMATION

Kashi: The City Where Death Leads to Liberation

In Indian philosophy, Kashi is known as the city of moksha (liberation).

It is believed that one who leaves the body here is freed from the cycle of rebirth.

Lord Shiva himself is regarded as the lord of Kashi, who, at the moment of death, whispers the Tarak Mantra into the soul’s ear and guides it on the path to liberation.

In Kashi, death is not seen as something to be feared, but as the gateway to final liberation and eternal peace.

Today, the city of Varanasi is also known as Banaras and Kashi, but ancient Hindu texts make it clear that these three names are not the same. Each name has its own special meaning and refers to a different geographical region, carrying a unique cultural and spiritual significance.

The geographical boundaries of Kashi

On the map, the boundaries of Kashi are marked in red, and only the area within this sacred line is considered the true Kashi region.

Just below this boundary lies the crescent-shaped Banaras Hindu University, positioned at the southern end and standing as one of the city’s most iconic landmarks.

*

Why Mahamana Malaviya Refused to Die in Kashi — A Story of True National Service

For every Hindu, no matter where they live in the world, there is a deeply held spiritual wish—to die in Kashi.

It is believed that taking one’s last breath in this sacred city grants moksha, freedom from the cycle of rebirth. For thousands of years, this belief has made Kashi the eternal spiritual heart of Sanatan Dharma.

Yet Pandit Madan Mohan Malaviya—revered freedom fighter, great educationist, and founder of Banaras Hindu University—made a decision that continues to astonish and inspire generations.

Despite living close to the southern boundary of Kashi, Mahamana Malaviya consciously chose not to die within its sacred limits.

This decision did not come from doubt or disbelief. On the contrary, Malaviya ji was a man of deep faith who respected Hindu traditions wholeheartedly. His choice was born out of something even greater—his unmatched devotion to the nation.

He believed that serving India was a higher calling than seeking personal salvation. For him, the motherland came before tradition, before comfort, and even before liberation itself.

He is believed to have said that he did not desire moksha; instead, he wished to be reborn so that he could continue serving his country.

To honor this resolve, Malaviya ji spent his final days at a lodge within the Banaras Hindu University campus—situated just outside the traditional sacred boundary of Kashi.

By passing away there, he knowingly gave up the promise of instant liberation, expressing his desire to return and serve India once again.

Mahamana Malaviya’s choice stands as a timeless lesson in selflessness. It teaches us that true devotion lies not only in spiritual belief, but in tireless service to the nation—and that for a true patriot, duty to the country is the highest form of worship.

Varanasi: The Ideal Place for Buddha’s First Teachings

“NOW WE HAVE A REAL COMMUNITY ,WHICH WE CALL OUR SANGHA . THE SANGHA IS THE COMMUNITY OF THOSE WHO LIVE IN HARMONY AND AWARENESS. WE MUST TAKE THE SEEDS OF AWAKENING AND SOW THEM IN ALL PLACES.”

Buddha did not choose Varanasi (Kashi) for his first sermon by chance. He decided on it because many strong and wise reasons made it perfect.

*

Buddha’s Quest Before Lighting the Lamp in Kashi

After many years of searching and meditation, Siddhartha Gautama became the Buddha—he attained enlightenment under the Bodhi Tree in Bodh Gaya.

He grasped many profound truths about life, suffering, and what brings peace. But enlightenment by itself is not enough: what matters is sharing that light. So Buddha decided to give his first sermon.

He chose Sarnath, near Kashi (now Varanasi), for this crucial moment. This sermon is known as Dhammacakkappavattana Sutta—the “Turning of the Wheel of Dharma.”

Why did he pick Sarnath / Kashi? The reasons are many: some immediate, some symbolic, some practical. Together, they reveal how thoughtful the Buddha’s choice was. Below are the main reasons, followed by what his first teaching included and how it shaped the future.


Reconnecting with His Former Companions

This statue shows Lord Buddha’s first sermon in the Deer Park at Sarnath, near Varanasi. He taught important lessons called the Four Noble Truths, the Middle Path, and the Eightfold Path.

In the statue, Buddha is sitting with his legs crossed in the lotus position. One of his hands is making a gesture like turning a wheel — this shows he is teaching. Behind or below him is a symbol of the wheel, and there are deer beside it, because it happened in a deer park.

Around him are five monks with shaved heads, listening very carefully. They were his first followers.

One strong immediate reason was to share his understanding with people whom he already knew and who cared about his spiritual journey.

Before enlightenment, Buddha had five companions—ascetics—who practiced with him. After he left extreme asceticism and went his own Middle Way (balance between harsh austerity and indulgence), these companions doubted his path. They left, thinking he had stopped being serious, because he didn’t do extreme penance like before.

After enlightenment, Buddha wanted to show them what he had realized. He wanted them to see that the path he found was not abandon­ing the spiritual life, but a deeper, truer one.

These five companions were in Sarnath / nearby. By going to Sarnath first, Buddha could teach them, help them understand, and invite them to be the first followers who understood his insights.

This shows how much compassion and friendship mattered in Buddha’s approach.


Sarnath / Kashi as a Place of Learning and Spiritual Openness

Relics from the Time of Buddha at Sarnath

Sarnath (also called Mrigadava, Rishipatana, Isipatana — names that mean Deer Park, Hermit-Abode, Place of Sages) was already known in ancient India as a place where seekers of truth, monks, ascetics, holy people came together.

Many teachers gave talks there. Many travellers, pilgrims, and scholars visited. It was a center where people asked questions, held debates, studied sacred books, learned meditation, and discussed philosophy.

Because the people there were used to different ideas and spiritual teachers, they had open minds. They were not locked into one way of thinking.

They cared about truth, ethics, goodness. This made Sarnath a fitting place for Buddha to introduce his new teaching.

His message of the Middle Way, avoiding extremes, of reducing suffering and finding peace, would be heard.


Geographical and Strategic Advantages

Choosing a place is also practical. Sarnath is close to Varanasi / Kashi, which was a major city in ancient India. Varanasi was (and is) one of the oldest continuously inhabited cities in the world.

It was a religious center for Hindus, a place of learning, pilgrimage, and ritual. It was well known.

From a city like Kashi, ideas can travel through traders, pilgrims, and students. Roads and river routes connected it to many parts of India.

Many people came there from far and wide. Also, being near a city helped in ensuring that the message would not stay small but spread.


Cultural and Religious Symbolism

Kashi / Varanasi already had deep religious importance. It was a center of Hindu religious ritual, holy texts, scholars, yoga, and philosophy.

Many thought that spiritual truth could be found there. By giving his first sermon there, Buddha was not separating from what was sacred before; instead, he was offering a reform, a new insight.

He gently challenged extremes in religious practice (like harsh self-punishment), but did not reject all that was good. This shows Buddha’s teachings as inclusive—not destructive, but renewing.

Also, choosing Sarnath / Kashi for the first sermon symbolized that the message was for all, not just for a small group. It was rooted in a spiritual soil already well known, so people could understand more easily.


Spiritual Meanings: The Deer Park, the Wheel, the Middle Way

The place itself — the forested deer park, quiet, natural — also had spiritual meaning.

It offers peace, calm, and the ideal setting for deep understanding. In a park, trees, deer, quiet sounds — all help one meditate, listen, think.

Buddha’s sermon was not about wars or politics, but about suffering, mind, and heart. Such teachings need calmness more than noise.

“Turning the Wheel of Dharma” is a powerful image: a wheel moves, spreads, carries things around. With his first sermon, the wheel of teaching began turning. The teachings would roll out, reach many hearts.

Also, Buddha taught the Middle Way — avoiding extremes of self-denial and self-indulgence. That teaching fits the idea of balance, peace, and mindfulness. A deer park, a calm place, helps suggest balance, peaceful observation of nature, and life.

*

~ When you learn something good, share it. Buddha didn’t keep his understanding to himself. He shared.

~ Choose places and times wisely. The right setting—quiet, calm, with people who are ready to hear—makes sharing ideas more powerful.

~Balance matters. Extreme behaviour (too much harshness, or too little responsibility) is often harmful. A middle way—mindful, kind, balanced—is often best.

~Traditions, even old ones, can carry meaning. But new ideas can build upon them, reform or improve, make them better. Buddha didn’t reject spiritual traditions; he showed how they could become more compassionate and true.

~Small beginnings can lead to big changes. One sermon in one deer park started a movement that has lasted thousands of years.


स्वामी विवेकानंद का अंतिम वाराणसी आगमन , और गोपाल लाल विला .

विवेकानंद ने अपना शरीर त्यागने से कुछ दिन पहले अपने आराध्य शिव की नगरी में जहाँ कुछ समय बिताया. ( गोपाल लाल विला) राजा काली कृष्ण ठाकुर का garden house

स्वामी जी के अंतिम दिनों  का साक्षी उनका निवास स्थल गोपाल लाल विला वर्तमान मे एक खण्डहर बन चुका है .

वाराणसी स्वामी विवेकानंद के प्रिय भगवान शंकर की नगरी है , स्वामी जी यहाँ पहले भी आते रहे थे परन्तु इस बार सन 1902 में उनका वाराणसी में आने का प्रायोजन स्वास्थ्य लाभ लेना था।

ये अलग बात है की स्वामी जी अपने को यहाँ भी जन -हित के विषयों से स्वयं को अलग न कर सके और गंभीर बीमारी की अवस्था में भी समाज सेवा के कार्यों जुड़े रहे.

————————————————————

स्वामी विवेकानंद का अंतिम वाराणसी आगमन और गोपाल लाल विला में ठहरना.

———————————————————-

         L.T कॉलेज का प्रवेश द्वार.

प्रवेश द्वार पर स्वामी विवेकानंद के लगे पोस्टर एक -दो वर्ष पुराने हैं।
इसके अतिरिक्त स्वामी विवेकानंद के यहाँ प्रवास के संबंध में कोई जानकारी नहीं दी गयी है।

वाराणसी नगर कचहरी के निकट अर्दली बाजार में L. T कॉलेज परिसर स्थित है।
वर्तमान में इस परिसर के अंदर , एक पुस्तकालय , एक प्राइमरी स्कूल , शिक्षा विभाग से जुड़े घर अक्षय पात्र मेगा किचन और एक पुराना मंदिर भी है।

वर्तमान में L. T COLLEGE के नाम से जाने जाने वाली ये जगह कभी राजा काली कृष्ण ठाकुर का Garden House (गार्डन हाउस) था। राजा काली कृष्ण ठाकुर के पिता जी का नाम गोपाल लाल था। इस भवन का निर्माण संभवतः उन्हीं के द्वारा करवाया गया था।

GARDEN HOUSE (गार्डन हाउस)

GARDEN HOUSE (गार्डन हाउस) 19 वीं शताब्दी के आरंभ और मध्य में वाराणसी में भारत कुछ प्रमुख राजाओं , व्यापारियों , के द्वारा विस्तृत भूमि पर विशाल भवनों का निर्माण कार्य करवाया गया था। ये सभी भवन एक बगीचे जैसे भूमि के मध्य स्थित होते थे इस कारण इन्हें गार्डन हाउस कहा जाता था।

उस दौर के वाराणसी में स्थित कुछ अन्य प्रमुख गार्डन हाउस

उस दौर में निर्मित कुछ गार्डन हाउस आज भी वाराणसी में देखे जा सकते हैं जैसे — काशी नरेश की नदेसरी कोठी , हथुआ नरेश की कोठी , नेपाल नरेश की कोठी , डालमिया भवन आदि।

राजा काली कृष्ण ठाकुर के गार्डन हाउस के मध्य स्थित एक सुन्दर और विशाल कोठी स्थित थी जिसे गोपाल लाल विला के नाम से जाना जाता था।

स्थानीय लोग इस भवन को सोंधा बास के नाम से भी जानते थे।

1902  मे विवेकानंद  का आना एक  दूसरा अर्थ रखता था, अब वो स्वामी विवेकानंद विश्वप्रसिद्ध ,दार्शनिक और विद्वान थे, परन्तु बेहद कमज़ोर और बीमार.

बंगाल के प्रसिद्ध लेखक शंकर ने अपनी किताब The monk  as man में chapter 4पेज 175 ,176  मे  उनकी 31 बिमारियों के बारे मे और  इन बिमारियों से दृहता से लड़ते हुए  सामाजिक भलाई मे लगे रहने का जिक्र  किया है.  

स्वामी जी इस बार बनारस आ कर  राजा  काली  कृष्ण ठाकुर  के गार्डन हाउस गोपाल लाल  विला  मे रुके .

स्थानीय लोग  इस जगह  को सोंधा बास  भी कहते थे .  यहाँ विवेकानंद जी लगभग एक महीना तक रुके .राजा  काली  कृष्ण ठाकुर  के गार्डन हाउस गोपाल लाल  विला  का अपने पत्रो मे जिक्र करते हुए इस स्थान को स्वास्थ्य के अनुकूल बताया था .

स्वास्थ्य  ख़राब होने के बाद भी यहाँ  सामाज़िक  गतिविधियों मे लगे लोगों से मिलते रहे  स्वामी जी से प्रभावित हो कर “दरिद्र नारायण सेवा समिति” “poor men’s relief association”  का गठन करने वाले चारु चंद्र दास,(स्वामी शुभानन्दा) सदाशिवनन्द (आप ही ने स्वामी जी की इस बार बनारस में आगवानी की और गोपाललाल विला में उनके प्रवास के बारे मे स्वामी विवेकानंद संस्मरण नाम से एक लेख लिखा) .

चारु चंद्र दास, जी लगभग प्रतिदिन स्वामी जी से मिलने गोपाल लाल भवन आया करते थे . आप लोगों के अनुरोध पर स्वामी जी ने संगठन का नाम” the Ramakrishna home of service”  कर दिया जो आगे चल कर वाराणसी का एक प्रमुख अस्पताल बना।

आज ये अस्पताल रामकृष्ण अस्पताल के नाम से विख्यात है और ये वाराणसी नगर का एक प्रमुख अस्पताल है। स्थानीय लोग इसको कौड़िया अस्पताल के नाम से भी जानते हैं। समाज सेवा मे लगे राजा भिनगा उदय प्रताप से भी उनके गार्डन घर पर जा कर मिले.  केदार घाट के पुजारी से भी मुलाकात की.

यहाँ से जाने के कुछ महीनों बाद ही(4july 1902) स्वामी जी मृत्यु हो गयी.

स्वामी जी के अंतिम दिनों  का साक्षी उनका निवास स्थल वर्तमान मे गोपाल लाल विला एक खण्डहर बन चुका है .क्या ही अच्छा होता की सरकार भारत की सांस्कृतिक राजधानी (cultural capital of India) वाराणसी मे इस खण्डहर को एक धरोहर रूप प्रदान करती.

भारत की सांस्कृतिक राजधानी मे  भारत की संस्कृति को बचाने वाले और सम्पूर्ण विश्व को भारत की संस्कृति से परिचित कराने वाले योद्धा सन्यासी (warrior monk) विवेकानंद की इस धरोहर को बचाने का प्रयास तो होना ही चाहिए.

———————————————————-

स्वामी विवेकानंद ने गोपाल लाल विला का ज़िक्र कहाँ किया है.

———————————————————-

स्वामी विवेकानंद ने स्वयं गोपाल लाल विला में रुकने और अपने अंतिम बार बनारस आने का जिक्र अपने अनेकों पत्रों में किया है। स्वामी विवेकानंद ने गोपाल लाल विला में ठहरने के दौरान विभिन्न लोगों को पत्र लिखे थे अथवा लोगों के पत्रों का उत्तर दिया था।

इन पत्रों में स्वयं स्वामी विवेकानंद ने गोपाल लाल विला उल्लेख किया है।

कोई भी व्यक्ति जिसकी इस विषय में रूचि हो वो स्वामी विवेकानंद के THE COMPLETE WORKS OF SWAMI VIVEKANANDA में उनके द्वारा वर्णित इस स्थान का वर्णन पढ़ सकता है।

THE COMPLETE WORKS OF SWAMI VIVEKANANDA ADVAITA ASHRAM KOLKATA द्वारा प्रकाशित है।

नोट :- ब्रिटिश शासन काल में वाराणसी को बनारस के नाम से जाना जाता था।

स्वामी विवेकानंद ने गोपाल लाल विला में ठहरने का जिक्र सर्वप्रथम 7 फ़रवरी 1902 में एक पत्र में किया है।

स्वामी विवेकानंद ने ये पत्र जोसेफिन मैकलियोड (Josephine MacLeod ) को लिखा था। इस पत्र के साथ दिए Foot -Note से पता चलता है की स्वामी जी का गोपाल लाल भवन में आगमन 4 फ़रवरी 1902 को हुआ था।

जोसेफिन मैकलियोड स्वामी विवेकानन्द की शिष्या थीं। इनका भारत से गहरा लगाव था। स्वामी विवेकानंद इन्हें टैंटीने अथवा जो उपनाम से संबोधित करते थे। इस पत्र में भी स्वामी इन्हें जो संबोधन किया है।

स्वामी विवेकानंद ने इस पत्र में अपने सकुशल वाराणसी पहुँचने का जिक्र किया है।

————————————————————-

गोपाल लाल विला में जब हुआ स्वामी जी को अपनी मृत्यु का पूर्वाभास .

————————————————————-

स्वामी जी ने अपनी एक अन्य शिष्या भगिनी निवेदिता को जिनका वास्तविक नाम मूल नाम ‘मार्गरेट एलिजाबेथ नोबल’ था को 4 मार्च 1902 में लिखे एक पत्र में अपनी बिमारियों का जिक्र किया था।
इस पत्र में भी गोपाल लाल विला का जिक्र है।

स्वामी जी ने भगिनी निवेदिता लिखे अपने पत्र में बताया है की उन्हें बैठने लिखने में समस्या हो रही है।
स्वामी जी निवेदिता को लिखी चिट्ठी में बताते हैं की उनकी तबियत ठीक है पर कभी भी बिगड़ सकती है।

स्वामी जी ने अपने सदा बुखार बने रहने और सांस लेने में होने वाली तकलीफ का जिक्र भी किया है

स्वामी विवेकानंद इस पत्र में निवेदिता से स्पष्ट कहते हैं की ये पत्र लिखते समय उनको ऐसा लग रहा है की शायद ये उनका अंतिम पत्र हो।

एक चित्रकार (KRIPA) की कल्पना GOPAL-LAL VILA (1902)

वाराणसी के युवा चित्रकार कृपा द्वारा 1902 में गोपाल लाल भवन कैसा दिखता रहा होगा का काल्पनिक भव्य रूप।

वर्तमान में गोपाल लाल विला